Thanks going out today to our coalition member, Boyd Allen who has a talent for getting to the real heart of the matter

Thanks going out today to our coalition member, Boyd Allen who has a talent for getting to the real heart of the matter. Today he is, as many of us have been, grappling with Minister Compton’s recent announcement about an amendment to the LPA and what it may really be about.

Appearances
“Being afraid you’ll look like a coward is the worst reason for doing anything.”
― John Irving, The Cider House Rules

Minister Compton’s recent release of a Lands Protection Act (LPA) amendment
focusing on limiting non-profit companies’ land limits, though puzzling in many ways,
should not have come as a surprise. It’s an election year and desperate times beget
desperate measures.
The rationale supporting this amendment is based on the role of non-profit
organizations allegedly encroaching on agricultural land. The vast majority of these do
not own enough land to be affected by this amendment. Others, such as the Island
Nature Trust, are specifically exempted as recipients under the Government of
Canada Ecological Gifts Program. The Buddhist organizations in Kings County are the
only ones which appear to own more land than allowed by it.
It is worth noting that this amendment was crafted and released while IRAC was still
charged with conducting a much-anticipated investigation on Buddhist land holdings
as directed by the Minister’s predecessor. The acreage owned by the non-profit
Buddhist organizations are a matter of public record. However, the relationship with
their directors, nuns, monks, laypeople, family members and an array of related
companies and foundations was to be a key element of the Inquiry. Despite lack of
details of this investigation or an established timeline, any findings emanating from it
should be reflected in any related legislative changes.
The administration of the “land holding declarations” and any resultant “divestiture
schedules” carried within this amendment is the responsibility of “The Commission” –
meaning IRAC, a public tribunal struggling to retain public trust and one this
government has committed to restructure.
If preserving agricultural land is indeed this government’s priority, there are more
significant issues which demand immediate attention. The lack of coherent land use
planning for 90% of PEI’s landmass results in haphazardly approved development and
with it staggering loss of both agricultural land and precious biodiversity. A promised
island-wide land use plan is becoming more aspirational than a work in progress.

Rory Francis’ revelation that for decades there has been an unwritten 30% LPA non-
resident acreage threshold based on the old school district boundaries surely

deserves immediate attention but hasn’t yet been acknowledged.

The thousands of acres designated for non-development in the last decade through
another amendment to the LPA are beginning to lose this designation and therefore
have a profound impact on land use, availability, and price. The province isn’t even
aware of the total acreage this represents. It is currently administered by IRAC.
Neither the government nor IRAC has displayed any appetite to enforce the LPA
regulation on Beneficial Ownership. This ongoing omission avoids any direct
confrontation with Cavendish Farms and other large corporations, including
ironically, GEBIS/GWBI.
So, what would Minster Compton’s amendment accomplish? Already the Buddhist
community feels unfairly targeted, and thus potentially justified in launching legal
action. This is despite the acreage addressed in the amendment being relatively small
and potentially divested in a manner not disruptive to their objectives.
This amendment is an attempt to appear to proactively grapple with the persisting
concerns surrounding Buddhist land holdings in Kings County while not challenging
Cavendish Farms or honestly supporting their own regulatory framework. It changes
little while diverting attention and precious resources from productively addressing
our land crises.
Boyd Allen
Coalition for the Protection of PEI Lands

Share On Social Media

About the site

Stay up-to-date on Coalition activites here.

Find us

Address

81 Prince Street

Charlottetown, PE

c1A 4R3

Related Posts

UPCOMING FORUM

https://www.peicanada.com/island_farmer/silencing-of-the-land-topic-for-coalition-forum/article_377a8576-c754-11ee-b125-eb0a0b7d3ad0.html#tncms-source=block-contextual

Read More »

P

P.E.I.’s Move to Limit Non-profit Land Holdings Requires ‘Reasonable Justification,’ Says Buddhist Group by Kerry Campbell Monday, November 9th, 2026 A spokesperson for the Great

Read More »