P.E.I.’s Move to Limit Non-profit Land Holdings Requires ‘Reasonable Justification,’ Says Buddhist Group
by Kerry Campbell
Monday, November 9th, 2026
A spokesperson for the Great Enlightenment Buddhist Institute Society (GEBIS) says he suspects Buddhists on P.E.I. may have been targeted by the provincial government with proposed legislation that would force non-profit groups to sell off land.
“Obviously there’s no evidence,” said Walter Tsai, public communication liaison for GEBIS, told CBC News. “But somehow I do suspect that Buddhist people, our community, is unproportionally burdened by the amendment.”
The proposed amendment to the Lands Protection Act would reduce the land ownership limit for non-profit corporations in the province from the current 1,214 hectares (3,000 acres) down to about 161 hectares (400 acres).
For GEBIS that would mean being forced to divest around 72 hectares (178 acres) of the roughly 233 hectares (578 acres) the group currently owns. That includes land in eastern P.E.I. where its monastery and dormitories are situated, along with forested land and 100 acres of arable land that’s part of a former tobacco farm the monks now use to grow wheat and organic vegetables.
Another Buddhist group, the Great Wisdom Buddhist Institute, would be in a similar situation.
Tsai said his group has been unable to get answers from the province on questions such as what the rationale is for the change. He said a 14-day period for public feedback on the amendment is too short.
“I think it demands a… reasonable justification,” he said.
“If you’re treating Buddhist organizations differently without a clear justification, is that not discriminatory?”
Amendment an effort to free up farmland, minister says
Buddhist land holdings in eastern P.E.I., where provincial Land Minister Darlene Compton holds her seat, have been a contentious issue for years, with claims the organizations control far more land than what they actually hold title to.
Last year, Compton’s predecessor Steven Myers ordered the Island Regulatory and Appeals Commission, which administers the Lands Protection Act, to conduct an investigation. That is still underway.
When asked if the proposed amendment is an attempt to reduce Buddhist land holdings on the Island, Compton said “it’s an effort to reduce the land holdings of any not-for-profit organization who has in excess of two, three, four hundred acres, whatever that total is going to be.”
Compton said her department doesn’t know how many non-profit groups would be affected by the change.
The overall goal, she said, is to free up more land for agriculture.
“Does a not-for-profit corporation need to own up to 3,000 acres, and why?” she said. “If we are going to protect land on P.E.I., then I think that is an important question.”
Compton said she believes the Catholic Church wouldn’t be affected by the bill, because its 687-plus hectares, or more than 1,700 acres, are split among numerous parishes.
The proposed bill also includes a carve-out that would exempt conservation groups like Island Nature Trust from the new limit.
Boyd Allen, a member of the Coalition for the Protection of P.E.I. Lands, said he doesn’t think the amendment would have “any impact at all on agricultural acreage” because there are too few non-profits that would be affected.
By contrast, he pointed to a government program — the Land Identification Program — through which hundreds of thousands of acres have been protected for non-development use when purchased by non-resident landowners, then had that protection automatically removed 10 years later.
He described the government’s proposed amendment as an attempt “to appear to grapple with the contentious issue involving Buddhist land holdings in Kings County.”
Allen said a better way to uphold the Lands Protection Act with groups like the Buddhists and large companies like the Irvings would be to enforce language in the act meant to prevent multiple corporations under the same control from stacking up land limits.
Tsai said GEBIS “wouldn’t rule out the option” of launching a legal challenge if the amendment is passed and the group is ordered to divest land.
He said many monks are Canadian citizens who call the Island home and “share the vision” of a better future for the Island.
“I hope this process can help us achieve that rather than divide the community and [have us] blaming each other,” he said.
The province is accepting public feedback on the bill until Tuesday. A spokesperson for the Department of Land said Compton plans to table the bill during the current fall sitting of the legislature.